Unraveling the Classics of Sociology: Durkheim, Marx, and Weber

Have you ever stopped to think about why certain rules and norms exist in our society? From the way we behave in school to the laws we follow daily, all of this is studied by Sociology. In the 3rd year of High School, we dive into the study of the classics of Sociology to better understand how thinkers like Durkheim, Marx, and Weber explain the functioning of societies. Understanding these theories helps to decipher the mechanisms behind social structures and the factors that influence our behavior.

Imagine how it would be to understand the roots of social problems we see in the news, such as economic inequality, political crises, and social movements. The ideas of Durkheim, Marx, and Weber offer valuable tools to analyze these phenomena. By exploring these concepts, you not only acquire academic knowledge but also develop skills to reflect on the world around you and seek ways to transform it.

Did You Know?

Did you know that Karl Marx spent much of his life in London, where he wrote his most famous work, 'Capital'? He used to frequent the British Museum's library to study and write. Today, the library still exists and is considered a tourist attraction for those interested in his work. Who would have thought that such a common place could give rise to revolutionary ideas that impacted the entire world?

Warming Up

Let's start with Émile Durkheim, who is known for his analysis of 'social facts'. Durkheim argues that there are norms and values that are external to the individual and exert pressure on them. For example, the expected behavior pattern in a classroom is a social fact that influences how you behave. Another important concept introduced by Durkheim is 'anomie', which describes a situation in which social norms become confused or absent, leading to a state of disorientation.

Karl Marx, on the other hand, focused on 'historical materialism', the idea that material and economic conditions are the foundation for social structure and historical changes. He believed that the history of societies is marked by the class struggle between oppressors and the oppressed. Max Weber brought a different perspective, emphasizing 'social action', that is, the actions of individuals that have a subjective meaning and are directed towards the behavior of others. Weber also introduced 'ideal types' as tools for analyzing complex aspects of society.

I Already Know That...

On a sheet of paper, write down everything you already know about Classics of Sociology.

I Want to Know About...

On the same sheet of paper, write down everything you want to learn about Classics of Sociology.

Learning Objectives

• Understand the main ideas of Durkheim, Marx, and Weber and their contributions to Sociology.
• Recognize and analyze how these theories can be applied to understand contemporary social problems.
• Develop the skill of argumentation and debate, using sociological concepts.
• Increase critical reflection capacity about society and its functioning.
• Strengthen empathy and understanding of peers' perspectives during discussions and debates.

Émile Durkheim and Social Facts

Émile Durkheim was one of the pioneers of Sociology and introduced the concept of 'social facts'. For Durkheim, social facts are ways of acting, thinking, and feeling that exist outside of the individual but exert pressure on them. Think of the behavioral norms in a classroom, or the traditions of a holiday. These are examples of social facts that influence our actions without us realizing it. Durkheim argued that to understand society, we need to study these social facts as things, analyzing their characteristics and influences.

Another key concept introduced by Durkheim is 'anomie'. Anomie occurs when the norms that regulate social life become confused or disappear, leading to a state of disorientation. In times of economic crisis, for example, the norms that guide financial behavior may become uncertain, resulting in stress and anxiety. Durkheim used this concept to explain phenomena such as the increase in suicide rates during periods of social instability.

Durkheim also emphasized the importance of social cohesion, which is the force that keeps society united. He believed that education and social institutions play a vital role in promoting social cohesion by transmitting norms and values that help maintain order. Thus, Durkheim saw society as a more complex entity than just the simple sum of its individuals, where each element plays a crucial role in maintaining balance.

Reflections

Think of a moment when you felt pressured to follow a social norm, such as a dress code or a family tradition. How do these norms influence your behavior and emotions? What happens when these norms become confused or nonexistent? Reflecting on these questions can help you better understand the concept of anomie and the importance of social cohesion in our daily lives.

Karl Marx and Historical Materialism

Karl Marx is widely known for his theory of 'historical materialism', which suggests that material and economic conditions are the basis for social structure and historical changes. Marx argued that the history of societies is a history of class struggles, where different social groups compete for resources and power. He divided society into two large classes: the bourgeoisie, who control the means of production, and the proletariat, who sell their labor power.

According to Marx, economic conditions determine the superstructure of society, which includes political, legal, and cultural institutions. For example, he believed that laws and systems of government are shaped by the economic interests of the dominant class. This means that to understand social changes, we need to look at the economic relations and class struggles that shape them.

Marx also introduced the concept of 'alienation', which describes the sense of disconnection that workers feel in relation to the product of their labor. In a capitalist system, workers have no control over the production process and therefore feel alienated from the products they create. This alienation is not only economic but also social and emotional, affecting the way individuals relate to themselves and to others.

Reflections

Have you ever felt disconnected or alienated from an activity you were doing, such as work or study? What caused that feeling of disconnection? By reflecting on these experiences, you can begin to better understand Marx's concept of alienation and how economic conditions can influence our emotions and social relationships.

Max Weber and Social Action

Max Weber brought a unique perspective to Sociology by focusing on 'social action'. For Weber, social action is any human conduct that possesses a subjective meaning and is oriented towards the behavior of others. In other words, our actions are influenced by our intentions and by how we believe others will react. For example, choosing specific words when speaking with a friend or acting in a certain way in a job interview are social actions that consider others' responses.

Weber also developed the concept of 'ideal types', which are theoretical models that help analyze complex aspects of society. These ideal types are not exact descriptions of reality, but tools for understanding social phenomena. For example, Weber used the ideal type of 'capitalism' to analyze how different societies adopted capitalist economic practices in distinct ways.

Additionally, Weber explored the relationship between ethics and economics in his famous work 'The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism'. He argued that Protestant ethics, with its focus on hard work and frugality, played a crucial role in the development of modern capitalism. This perspective shows how beliefs and values can profoundly influence economic and social structures.

Reflections

Think of an occasion when you adjusted your behavior based on the expectation of how others would react. How was this action influenced by your understanding of others' intentions and perceptions? Reflecting on these situations can help you better understand Weber's concept of social action and the importance of ideal types in analyzing societies.

Impact on Current Society

The theories of Durkheim, Marx, and Weber continue to impact contemporary society in significant ways. Durkheim's ideas about social facts and anomie are extremely relevant when considering modern problems such as mental health and social cohesion. In a world where norms are constantly changing, understanding these concepts can help us create healthier and more balanced social environments.

Marx and Weber, in turn, provide us with valuable tools to analyze economic inequalities and the power dynamics that still exist in our societies. Marx's class struggle is evident in social movements seeking economic justice, while Weber's ideal types help us understand the variations in economic and political practices around the world. By studying their theories, we can develop a deeper understanding of the forces shaping our society and seek ways to promote positive change.

Recapping

• Durkheim and Social Facts: Durkheim introduced the concept of 'social facts', which are ways of acting, thinking, and feeling external to the individual, but which exert pressure on them. He also emphasized the importance of social cohesion and 'anomie', a situation where social norms become confused or absent.
• Marx and Historical Materialism: Karl Marx focused on 'historical materialism', arguing that material and economic conditions are the basis for social structure and historical changes. He also discussed 'class struggle' and the concept of 'alienation'.
• Weber and Social Action: Max Weber brought the perspective of 'social action', where individuals' actions have a subjective meaning and are directed towards the behavior of others. He also developed 'ideal types' and explored the relationship between ethics and economics.
• Impact of Theories: The theories of Durkheim, Marx, and Weber continue to impact contemporary society, providing valuable tools for analyzing modern problems such as economic inequality, mental health, and social cohesion.

Conclusions

• Durkheim helps us understand how norms and values influence our behavior and the importance of social cohesion.
• Marx offers us a lens to analyze economic inequalities and alienation at work, highlighting class struggle as a driver for social change.
• Weber teaches us about the importance of social actions and how values and beliefs can shape economic and social structures.
• The theories of the three sociologists provide us with tools for a critical analysis of contemporary societies and encourage us to seek solutions for social problems.
• Reflecting on these theories helps us develop skills of argumentation, empathy, and understanding of others' perspectives.

What I Learned?

• How do social norms influence your daily behavior and emotions?
• In what ways do current economic conditions affect your life and the lives of those around you?
• How are your actions shaped by the expectations and reactions of others in different social contexts?

Going Beyond

• Write a paragraph about a situation where you felt pressured to follow a social norm. How did this influence your emotions and actions?
• Analyze a current social problem using Marx's theory of historical materialism.
• Describe a situation where you adjusted your behavior based on the expectation of how others would react. Connect this experience to Weber's concept of social action.